Hello, F & A, hope everyone is studying.
I will provide my speculative answer later, so here are some very thought provoking questions in the spirit of our Fr Jules:
Can an immortal soul intentionally commit evil (if it is an truly begotten by God)?
Can a R+C soul-personality (a soul seed under development) commit intentionally evil deeds)?
What is a R+C soul-personality in your own understanding (the last is a freebie)